Skip to main content
Notable Settlement
Healthcare
$29 Million

Saint Vincent's Catholic Medical Centers — DOD Overpayment Retention

New York Health System Pays $29 Million for Retaining DOD Overpayments

By Angie KellyLast updated: February 17, 2025

Source: U.S. Department of Justice

TL;DR: New York Health System Pays $29 Million for Retaining DOD Overpayments This case resulted in a $29 Million resolution and demonstrates the impact of whistleblower protections in recovering funds from fraud.

Summary

A New York health system agreed to pay $29 million to resolve allegations that it knowingly retained inflated payments received from the Department of Defense for retired military members and their families. DOJ alleged the system learned that the fixed rate it was paid by DOD for providing care to military families and retirees was miscalculated, but nevertheless improperly retained and concealed the resulting overpayments rather than returning the excess funds.

Our Take

Overpayment retention cases often begin when someone in finance or billing discovers an error—and then leadership decides to keep quiet. The critical evidence is usually the moment of discovery and what happened next: who was told, what advice was given, and whether disclosure was considered and rejected. If you've seen an organization discover it was overpaid and choose concealment over repayment, document the decision-making chain and any communications about the "benefit" of not reporting.

Read the full article from the original source:

View Original Article

Opens in a new tab. Content from U.S. Department of Justice.

Notice

The summaries above are based on publicly available information released by the U.S. Department of Justice and are provided for informational purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice, investigative findings, or allegations by Disclosure Strategy. Our commentary reflects general, experience-based observations about how False Claims Act matters commonly arise and is not a statement about any party's liability.